The Trashing of Margaret Mead: Anatomy of an Anthropological Controversy (Studies in American Thought and Culture)

By Paul Shankman

In 1928 Margaret Mead released Coming of Age in Samoa, a desirable learn of the lives of adolescent ladies that reworked Mead herself into a tutorial big name. In 1983 anthropologist Derek Freeman released a scathing critique of Mead’s Samoan study, badly destructive her recognition. Resonating past educational circles, his case opposed to Mead tapped into vital public matters of the Nineteen Eighties, together with sexual permissiveness, cultural relativism, and the nature/nurture debate. In venues from the New York Times to the television convey Donahue, Freeman argued that Mead were “hoaxed” by way of Samoans whose blameless lies she took at face value.
    In The Trashing of Margaret Mead, Paul Shankman explores the numerous dimensions of the Mead-Freeman controversy because it built publicly and because it performed out privately, together with the non-public relationships, expert rivalries, and larger-than-life personalities that drove it. delivering a serious point of view on Freeman’s arguments, Shankman studies key questions on Samoan sexuality, the alleged hoaxing of Mead, and the that means of the talk. Why have been Freeman’s arguments so with no trouble permitted through pundits outdoors the sphere of anthropology? What did Samoans themselves imagine? Can Mead’s popularity be salvaged from the quicksand of controversy? Written in an interesting, transparent type and in response to a cautious overview of the proof, The Trashing of Margaret Mead illuminates questions of putting up with importance to the academy and beyond.
2010 individual Lecturer in Anthropology on the American Museum of normal History
The Trashing of Margaret Mead reminds readers of the pitfalls of academia. It urges students to prevent own assaults and to have interaction in fit debate. The booklet redeems Mead whereas additionally redeeming the sector of anthropology. through exhibiting the distinctiveness of the Mead-Freeman case, Shankman locations his endured self assurance in academia, students, and the sphere of anthropology.”—H-Net Reviews

Show description

Quick preview of The Trashing of Margaret Mead: Anatomy of an Anthropological Controversy (Studies in American Thought and Culture) PDF

Best Anthropology books

The Elementary Forms of Religious Life

"Karen Fields has given us a greatest new translation of the best paintings of sociology ever written, one we can't be embarrassed to assign to our scholars. moreover she has written an excellent and profound advent. The book of this translation is an celebration for basic social gathering, for a veritable 'collective effervescence.

Ethnomusicology: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions)

Ethnomusicologists think that every one people, not only these we name musicians, are musical, and that musicality is among the crucial touchstones of the human event. This perception increases enormous questions on the character of song and the character of humankind, and ethnomusicologists argue that to correctly deal with those questions, we needs to research tune in all its geographical and ancient range.

The Harkis: The Wound That Never Heals

During this haunting chronicle of betrayal and abandonment, ostracism and exile, racism and humiliation, Vincent Crapanzano examines the tale of the Harkis, the zone of 1000000 Algerian auxiliary troops who fought for the French in Algeria’s battle of independence. After tens of millions of Harkis have been massacred via different Algerians on the finish of the battle, the survivors fled to France the place they have been put in camps, a few for so long as 16 years.

Colonial Situations: Essays on the Contextualization of Ethnographic Knowledge (History of Anthropology)

As eu colonies in Asia and Africa grew to become self sufficient international locations, because the usa engaged in battle in Southeast Asia and in covert operations in South the USA, anthropologists puzzled their interactions with their matters and frightened in regards to the political outcomes of government-supported study.

Additional resources for The Trashing of Margaret Mead: Anatomy of an Anthropological Controversy (Studies in American Thought and Culture)

Show sample text content

Robert Staughton and Helen Merrell Lynd, of their vintage sociological examine of the interval in Muncie, Indiana (known via the pseudonym Middletown), pronounced that new applied sciences like vehicles and flicks have been altering the way in which youngsters interacted: The extra refined social lifetime of this day [1925] has introduced with it one other “problem” a lot mentioned by means of Middletown mom and dad, the it sounds as if expanding rest of a few of the normal prohibitions upon the techniques of girls and boys to every other’s individuals. . . . [I]n 1890 a “well-brought-up” boy and woman have been mostly forbidden to sit down jointly at the hours of darkness; yet movies and the car have lifted this taboo and, as soon as lifted, it is simple for the perform to develop into extensively prolonged. Buggy using in 1890 allowed just a slender variety of mobility; 3 to 8 [ p. m. ] have been regularly accredited hours for using, and being out after eight-thirty and not using a chaperone was once principally forbidden. In an vehicle, despite the fact that, a celebration may work to a urban midway around the nation in a day or night, and unchaperoned motor vehicle events as past due as nighttime, whereas topic to feedback, are usually not unheard of. thirteen 120 Mead and Coming of Age in Samoa autos and films supplied new destinations for teenagers to occasion. So did public dances and dance halls, not backed completely via non secular or civic agencies. Privately owned golf equipment supplied new possibilities for youth of alternative backgrounds to satisfy one another. there have been “fast” dances, just like the Charleston and early swing, which anxious traditionalists. As one girl evangelist declared, “Social dancing is the 1st and simplest step in the direction of hell. the 1st time a woman permits a guy to swing her round the dance flooring her intuition tells her she has misplaced anything she must have valuable. ”14 within the conventional American excellent, younger males have been presupposed to be gallant gents, protecting of a tender lady’s dignity and advantage; younger women have been alleged to be modest and chaste. yet children within the Nineteen Twenties have been overtly attracted to intercourse. video clips, dances, tune, magazines, and literature all used intercourse as a call for participation to visualize new relationships. well known magazines, corresponding to Telling stories, integrated tales like “Primitive Love,” “Indolent Kisses,” and “Innocents off track. ” A full-page commercial for an additional “sex-adventure” journal introduced: “Until 5 years in the past [1919], there has been nowhere women and men, girls and boys may perhaps flip to get an information of the principles of lifestyles. They have been despatched out into the realm completely unprepared to deal with existence. . . . Then got here real tale. ”15 real Confessions, which additionally begun its lengthy e-book run in 1919, supplied lifestyles classes in tales like “Playing with Fire,” with its teaser, “It was once just a little indiscretion however it ended in one other and nonetheless one other. ”16 by means of the Twenties a extra sexualized tradition used to be constructing within the public area. Smoking and consuming, previously thought of social vices between ladies, weren't in simple terms tolerated yet accredited in a few circles.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.03 of 5 – based on 20 votes