Language and Solitude: Wittgenstein, Malinowski and the Habsburg Dilemma

By Ernest Gellner

Ernest Gellner (1925-1995) has been defined as "one of the final nice principal eu polymath intellectuals." during this, his final booklet, he throws new mild on key figures of the 20th century: the thinker Wittgenstein, and Malinowski, founding father of glossy British social anthropology. Gellner exhibits how the concept of either males grew from a standard historical past of assumptions approximately human nature, society, and language. He ties jointly issues that preoccupied him, epitomizing his trust that philosophy--far from "leaving every thing because it is"--is approximately very important historic, social and private matters.

Show description

Preview of Language and Solitude: Wittgenstein, Malinowski and the Habsburg Dilemma PDF

Best Anthropology books

The Elementary Forms of Religious Life

"Karen Fields has given us a most appropriate new translation of the best paintings of sociology ever written, one we can't be embarrassed to assign to our scholars. furthermore she has written an excellent and profound creation. The ebook of this translation is an party for basic party, for a veritable 'collective effervescence.

Ethnomusicology: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions)

Ethnomusicologists think that every one people, not only these we name musicians, are musical, and that musicality is among the crucial touchstones of the human event. This perception increases enormous questions about the character of tune and the character of humankind, and ethnomusicologists argue that to correctly deal with those questions, we needs to research track in all its geographical and old variety.

The Harkis: The Wound That Never Heals

During this haunting chronicle of betrayal and abandonment, ostracism and exile, racism and humiliation, Vincent Crapanzano examines the tale of the Harkis, the zone of one million Algerian auxiliary troops who fought for the French in Algeria’s struggle of independence. After tens of millions of Harkis have been massacred via different Algerians on the finish of the battle, the survivors fled to France the place they have been positioned in camps, a few for so long as 16 years.

Colonial Situations: Essays on the Contextualization of Ethnographic Knowledge (History of Anthropology)

As ecu colonies in Asia and Africa grew to become self sustaining international locations, because the usa engaged in battle in Southeast Asia and in covert operations in South the US, anthropologists wondered their interactions with their matters and nervous concerning the political outcomes of government-supported examine.

Additional resources for Language and Solitude: Wittgenstein, Malinowski and the Habsburg Dilemma

Show sample text content

At the one hand, he does say that even summary proposal can't sever its hyperlinks with sensible involvement. One passage makes this sound fairly risk free, an insignificant insistence on checking out: `The chemist or the physicist is aware the that means of his so much summary recommendations eventually at the foundation of his acquintance with chemical and actual approaches within the laboratory' (ibid. : 358). This sentence may come from a few positivist manifesto. it can be learn as af®rming, within the spirit of Ernst Mach, a few form of operationalism: the linkage of suggestions to the operations fascinated with their checking out. what's at factor is whether or not cultural perform validates recommendations and even if all 154 Malinowski cultural platforms are both legitimate, or no matter if, to the contrary, it really is attainable to pass judgement on rationally among them. in this aspect the proof touching on Malinowski is under conclusive. I favor the sooner Malinowski, who ®rmly upheld the excellence among the 2 varieties of inspiration which he accordingly disavowed. it really is, notwithstanding, very fascinating that evidently he went via a improvement very analogous to Wittgenstein's, no matter if this modification was once much less severe and attracted incomparably much less realization. maybe this used to be the highbrow undercurrent of the time, and there's different examples (e. g. Heidegger's improvement at the foundation of the instructing of Husserl). 31 The (un)originality of Malinowski and Wittgenstein The similarities among Malinowski's and Wittgenstein's view of language are notable and demanding and the query clearly arises even if Wittgenstein borrowed, consciously or differently, from Malinowski. If he did, he definitely didn't recognize it. Malinowski was once undoubtedly the ®rst to submit the action-involved, cultureembedded view of language, and he did so on the very time whilst Wittgenstein was once nonetheless dedicated to the `mirror' or `brass-rubbing' thought of language, and the complete irrelevance of tradition to the genuine functionality of concept and language. furthermore, in 1923 Malinowski released his rules as an Appendix to The that means of which means, coauthored through C. ok. Ogden, who was once while Wittgenstein's translator. a fascinating and hugely authoritative contribution to this query appears to be like within the kind of a letter from Sir Raymond Firth to the days Literary complement, dated 17 March 1995. Firth was once Malinowski's student, colleague, and successor, in addition to editor of the posthumous Festschrift to Malinowski (Man and tradition) during which his erstwhile students jointly expressed their highbrow and different indebtedness to him. Firth was once as regards to Malinowski intellectually, in my opinion and professionally, and his perspectives as a result deserve the maximum appreciate. Firth tells us that Wittgenstein did obtain a duplicate of The that means of which means (containing the appropriate Appendix by means of Malinowski) `soon after it seemed, and often appeared very dismissive of it. He would possibly not also have glanced at Malinowski's essay . . . any resemblance of their perspectives should be unintentional' (Firth 1995).

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.20 of 5 – based on 50 votes